Case Timeline

  • September 15, 2016: Crash on Interstate 75 in Hernando County, Florida.
  • February 27, 2018: Gregory Andriotis arrested in Volusia County on a Hernando County warrant and charged with one count of vehicular homicide and three counts of reckless driving causing serious bodily injury.
  • July 18, 2018: SJDC retained by a private attorney in a related wrongful death civil case.
  • November 2019: SJDC retained by the State Attorney’s Office to assist in the criminal case.
  • April 2023: Andriotis convicted at trial.
  • June 15, 2023: Andriotis sentenced to 30 years in prison.
  • January 3, 2025: Convictions affirmed by Florida’s Fifth District Court of Appeal.

Background

A family was stopped in traffic on Interstate 75 when their vehicle was rear ended at speed, setting off a chain reaction involving several vehicles. A nine year old boy was killed. Three other family members were seriously injured.

SJDC first worked on this crash in 2018 on a related civil matter, which is covered by a confidentiality agreement. The State Attorney’s Office brought SJDC into the criminal case in 2019.

The crash facts were not in dispute. There was no braking and no evasive action, visibility was clear, and the driver had time to react. The hard part was proving recklessness.

The Legal Problem

The charge was vehicular homicide, not distracted driving. The phone mattered because the State had to prove the driver acted with willful or wanton disregard for the safety of others. In Florida that takes more than negligence or inattention. It takes proof of a conscious disregard of a known danger.

At the time, no Florida court was known to have affirmed a vehicular homicide conviction built on mobile device distraction. News coverage reported it as the first texting and driving case to go to trial in Florida (WPTV, April 28, 2023) and described the verdict as a nationwide first (Tampa Bay 28, June 16, 2023).

The Forensic Limits

A motion in limine limited the admissible device evidence to activity after 3:28 p.m. The crash happened between 3:34 and 3:37 p.m. Most of the activity showing a pattern of distraction was off the table before the examination started.

Even so, the device showed sustained, deliberate use. The evidence at trial centered on Microsoft Excel being downloaded, installed and used. The broader pattern included:

  • Active voice calls
  • Viewing and trying to open a budget spreadsheet with multiple tabs
  • Downloading and installing Microsoft Excel
  • Accessing financial accounts
  • Credit card payments

To confirm what the data showed, SJDC tested comparable devices to establish how the Excel installation worked and what the user had to do to complete it.

Who Was Using the Phone

Forensic reports and testimony should stay neutral, so SJDC refers to “the device user” rather than naming a person. Here, the device tied back to Mr. Andriotis through his email addresses, his documents and his communications with known contacts. There was little doubt who was using it.

What Can Be Recovered Today

Forensic tools and mobile operating systems have come a long way since 2016. Today, examiners can often recover:

  • Foreground app timelines
  • Screen on and off state, and orientation
  • Screen interaction logs
  • App switching

Attorneys are also better prepared to argue for a wider data window. That would have helped here.

Lessons for Attorneys

  • Preserve early. Don’t wait until a device is lost, overwritten or reset.
  • Look at the whole picture. One isolated event rarely meets the threshold for recklessness.
  • Don’t rely on the custodian. Most people think keeping the phone is enough, then keep using it.
  • Expect spoliation claims. Adverse inference rulings are now common.
  • Bring in an expert early, for the technical work and to help educate the court on scope.

These cases can end in multimillion dollar verdicts. Between January and May 2025, SJDC was involved in five cases with spoliation claims.

Related News & Legal Coverage

Bottom Line

Digital forensics can close the evidence gap in distracted driving cases, especially when the law requires proof of a reckless state of mind. Missed evidence, late preservation or a narrow scope can hurt even the most serious prosecution.

Preserve early. Look broadly. Bring in an expert up front.

Call Now Button